Underpinned by multiple visual explorations, questions relating to material
permeate all fields of photography, from the creative process to presentation of
the resulting images. Drawing on the BnF’s extensive collection of contemporary
photographs, the exhibition reveals photographic material’s capacities for
metamorphosis, along with its possible disappearance. A sensory, incarnate
history of photography is presented through unique works by almost two
hundred French and foreign photographers.
Divided into four major parts, the exhibition explores the image-material’s possible
states in photography, analogue and digital alike.
The first part, “Tangible image, incarnate material”, shows how photographers such
as William Eggleston, Ann Mandelbaum and Denis Brihat transform photographed
material by, for example, utilising blur, close-up and variations of scale. Others,
such as Andreas Müller-Pohle, Philippe Gronon and Isabelle Le Minh, concentrate
on analysing all the textures of a photograph’s components: silver grain, gelatine,
pixels, paper, etc.
Philippe Gronon, Cuvette de développement n°18, 2021, BnF, Estampes et photographie, Philippe Gronon © ADAGP, Paris, 2023
With “Labile image, experimented material”, the exhibition goes on to evoke
materiality in the light of explorations carried out in the “kitchen”, from laboratory
to computer menu: analogical experiments on emulsions (Pierre Cordier’s chemigrams
and Marina Bério’s gum bichromate process mixed with her own blood) and
on photographic mediums (Ellen Carey’s folded photograms, Patrick Bailly-Maître-
Grand’s daguerreotypes and Almudena Romero’s prints on plants) are presented
in comparison with digital works by Thomas Ruff (“Substrates” series, created by
superimposition of several images gleaned from the internet ) and Lauren Moffatt
(repurposing of photogrammetry in the “Compost” series).
Thomas Ruff , Série Negative, 2016, BnF, Estampes et photographie, Thomas Ruff © ADAGP, Paris, 2023
“Hybrid image, metamorphosed material” highlights practices in which photography
hybridises with other artistic expressions (Anne-Lise Broyer and Paolo Gioli)
or, through its own resources, succeeds in suggesting effects of pictorial, graphic
or sculptural materials (Valérie Belin, Jean-Luc Tartarin and Laurent Millet).
The fourth and final part, “ Precarious image, weakened material”, presents works
that examine photography subjected to the passage of time and factors that may
lead to its gradual erasure (work on the photographic archives of Eric Rondepierre,
Joan Fontcuberta, Hideyuki Ishibashi, Lisa Sartorio, Oscar Muñoz, etc.) along with
ephemeral materialisations that give rise to evanescent images (Michael Snow’s
holograms) or spectral, latent images (Rosella Bellusci, Smith, Vittoria Gerardi and
Alain Fleischer).
© Anne-Lise Broyer, Le Lys, Série 'Le langage des fleurs', 2021 BnF, Estampes et photographie, Anne-Lise Broyer © ADAGP, Paris, 2023
Although, in the works presented, the medium appears to be more important than
the subject, the two are closely related nonetheless, and despite the diversity of
practices, a good many photographers prioritise depictions evocative of landscape,
the body and nature. Delivering a rich visual grammar in which bridges are built
between early photographic processes and contemporary technologies, these
artists also give thought to the complex relationships between photography, society,
nature and technology, indicative of their commitment to an ecology of the image.
Payram, Deux ou trois choses que je sais d’elle, 1995-2021, Tirages argentiques couleur d’après négatif Polaroï d 55, noir & blanc (non lavé , non fixé ), 35 x 25 cm, BnF, Estampes et photographie © Payram, Courtesy Galerie Maubert
Jean Luc Tartarin, Série « Re-prendre - Fleurs », 2018, BnF, Estampes et photographie © Jean-Luc Tartarin, 2018
Morvarid K, série This too shall pass, [2020-2022], BnF, Estampes et photographie, Morvarid K © ADAGP, Paris, 2023
Thomas Paquet, Et pendant ce temps le soleil tourne, S13-1, 2021, BnF, Estampes et photographie © Thomas Paquet